Many shower replacements, and most tub to shower conversions, can be finished in one day when the new base and walls fit the existing space, while a traditional tile remodel takes far longer because tile has a long install. This guide shows what fits in a single day, what stretches the schedule, what real customers wrote about their install days, and how the approach compares with a traditional remodel.
A one day install works when the job is a replacement in the same footprint: the old base, tub or surround comes out, the opening is checked, a new base is set and trimmed to fit, wall panels go up, the valve and trim are installed, and the plumbing is connected and tested. Many shower replacements fit that pattern, and most tub to shower conversions do as well, because the new base goes into the space the tub occupied.
Two things make it possible. The materials are made to install as a system, with a one piece base and full wall panels instead of many individual tiles that each need setting and grouting; Samuel Mueller bases are trimmable and BathWraps® offers custom bases from 30 to 84 inches, so the base is fit to the opening rather than the opening rebuilt around the base. And the crew arrives with the work already planned, because the base size, wall pattern, door and fixtures were settled at the consultation.
Jean S. put the result simply in a Google review: "Would say it was a great experience getting a brand new shower in just one day." That is the typical outcome when the space is standard and nothing unexpected sits behind the wall.
It starts with protecting the house. Krzysztof O. noticed it right away, writing that the crew "had tarps down from the door, to the job". The old shower or tub comes out next, and that is the moment any hidden damage shows up. If there is a soft stud or a failing drain line, it is shown to you and priced before it is repaired, so the plan for the rest of the day is clear.
Then the new system goes in: the base, the wall panels, the valve and the trim, with a plumber making and testing the connections. Several reviews name the plumber alongside the installers, which shows how the day is split between installation and plumbing work.
The day ends with cleanup and a walkthrough. Tracey F. wrote that the crew "double checked with me everything that the salesman and I had discussed", and that when they finished, "which was done on time and less than a day, they had cleaned up so well you would have never known that construction had been done in my house." Ask to see how everything works before the crew leaves.
Scope is the usual reason. Removing a large whirlpool or an oversized tub and building a walk in shower in its place is a bigger job than a same size swap. Becca K. described exactly that project: "We had a whirlpool from the 80s taken out and replaced it with a walk in shower." The installers, she wrote, "put in a full 12 hour day to get our shower completed, which was a big job."
Surprises are the second reason. A stud that needs replacing or a faulty drain pipe found behind the old wall adds work, which James Z. described when a stud was replaced and the plumber replaced a faulty drain pipe. Parts are the third. Krzysztof O. wrote that "there was a problem with the tub in the beginning when they arrived, so they disconnected their trailer and went all the way back to get the right one", and the crew "still finished the job before dinner!!!"
None of this means a job will run long. It means a realistic plan allows for it, and a good installer tells you what was found and what it changes before the day goes on.
Longer, and usually much longer. A traditional tile remodel is built in stages. The old surround is torn out, the wall is prepared and waterproofed, tile is set piece by piece, and grout and any sealing need time before the shower can be used. Natural stone follows the same sequence with added sealing. Each stage waits on the one before it, so the bathroom can be out of service far longer than a single day.
Tracey F. had lived through it. Comparing her new install with a shower she had put in at a previous home, she wrote that "for no reason known to me, it took 2 weeks for the job to get done." A stretched timeline like that is what people mean when they call tile a long install.
The long timeline is the price of a custom tile job. For some homeowners it is worth paying. For a household with a single bathroom, two weeks without a shower is a real cost, and that is the case the next sections look at.
Set side by side, the two approaches differ most in time, maintenance and how much of the household is disrupted. The comparison below uses only the material facts and the customer experiences described on this page, drawn from Google reviews, where the company holds a 5.0 star rating across 61 reviews as of September 30, 2026.
A one day install trades some design freedom for speed and easy upkeep. The look of tile comes from simulated patterns, such as the Samuel Mueller Pioneer and Monterey collections or the BathWraps® Signature collection, rather than real tile, and in return there is no grout to scrub. A traditional remodel offers any tile you can find, at the cost of a long install, grout maintenance and, for stone, sealing. Both can include safety features such as grab bars and a low threshold entry, and both should come with a clear written price before work begins. Here the price is exact, accurate to the penny, with no hidden fees, and the work carries the Lifetime Warranty and Workmanship Guarantee.
One day install vs traditional tile remodel
| Factor | One day system install | Traditional tile remodel |
|---|---|---|
| Typical time | As little as one day for many installs | A long install; one reviewer's previous shower took 2 weeks |
| Grout | None; tile looks are simulated | Grout scrubbing |
| Corners and seams | Solid surface one piece base and walls, or acrylic panels finished with color matched SeamLock | Grout lines at every tile |
| Surface | Nonporous, antimicrobial solid surface or acrylic | Porous grout between tiles |
| Bigger scopes | A whirlpool removal can take a full 12 hour day | Adds to an already long schedule |
Source: Samuel Mueller and BathWraps® product facts and verified Google reviews (Jean S., Tracey F., Becca K.)
Because the household cannot shower anywhere else while the work is underway. Small homes are common across the service area, from Milwaukee bungalows and Fond du Lac's compact prewar houses to the condos and apartments of Madison and Waukesha, and a home that size usually has a single bathroom, often the hall bath that the whole family shares.
In that house, the difference between one day and two weeks is not a convenience. It decides whether someone showers at a neighbor's, joins a gym or stays with family until the job is done. For an older homeowner, losing the only shower can mean losing the routine that keeps them independent.
That is the case where a one day install earns its keep. If your home has a second full bath, a longer project is easier to live with, and the choice can rest more on look and budget. If it does not, ask at the consultation how long your specific job will take, and plan the day around it.
Only the day itself, because the work is indoors. Wisconsin winters are long and snowy, and Wausau is the coldest place in the service area. Snow affects whether the crew can reach the house safely and how much salt and slush gets tracked in, which is why the tarps go down from the door before the old unit comes out.
When a storm closes the roads, the job moves. Mike L. described that in his Google review, thanking the project manager, who was "just as professional as we had to reschedule due to a late season snowstorm that paralyzed the whole state last Monday." The same review praises the result: "Jon and Andy did a superb job on the removal and installation of our new shower/tub."
Summer is the easy season, and nothing about warm weather slows indoor bathroom work, so the choice of month comes down to your own calendar rather than the forecast.
Sources: Verified Google reviews (Jean S., Tracey F., Becca K., Krzysztof O., Mike L., James Z.); EPA, A Brief Guide to Mold, Moisture and Your Home.
Most tub to shower conversions are completed in one day, because the new shower base fits the space the tub occupied and the wall panels install as a system. Larger jobs, such as taking out a whirlpool or an oversized tub, can take longer; one customer described her whirlpool to walk in shower conversion as "a full 12 hour day". The consultation is where your own timeline gets set.
Not because of the speed. The time saved comes from the system, either a Premium Samuel Mueller System with a base compression molded under 5,000 psi or a Signature BathWraps® System in nonporous virgin acrylic, rather than from skipping steps. The installers are employed by the company rather than subcontracted, and the work carries the Lifetime Warranty and Workmanship Guarantee: the lifetime product warranty comes from the manufacturer, and American Shower Company backs its installation with its workmanship guarantee. If anything small needs attention later, an installer comes back to make it right.
Clear the bathroom of personal items, make a clear path from the door to the bathroom, and plan to keep pets away from the work area. The crew lays tarps from the door to the job so your floors stay protected, and the old unit leaves the same way. If the only shower in the house is being replaced, shower the night before; many jobs finish the same day, but larger scopes can run into the evening.
It is shown to you and priced before it is repaired, so nothing changes without your approval. James Z. wrote that "A stud was replaced and the plumber found a faulty drain pipe and replaced it, definitely above and beyond." Fixing it while the wall is open matters, since EPA guidance says water damaged areas should be dried within 24 to 48 hours to prevent mold growth, and only a moldy patch smaller than about 10 square feet is something a homeowner can usually handle alone.
Yes. The work is indoors, but the crew still has to reach the house safely, so a storm that closes roads moves the appointment. Mike L. wrote about rescheduling "due to a late season snowstorm that paralyzed the whole state last Monday" and praised how professionally it was handled. Wausau and the Fox Valley get long, snowy winters, so winter dates are planned around the forecast and the project manager calls you directly if a date has to move.
For most homeowners whose new shower fits the existing footprint, yes, because the bathroom is back in use in as little as one day instead of weeks of tile work. Speed is the visible gain; the lasting one is the surface. Premium Samuel Mueller Systems, with a solid surface base compression molded under 5,000 psi, and Signature BathWraps® Systems in nonporous virgin acrylic both have no real grout to scrub or reseal, while tile needs a long install and grout upkeep. Tracey F. wrote in a Google review that a shower at a previous home "took 2 weeks for the job to get done," while hers was "less than a day." The case weakens if you want to move walls or plumbing, which needs traditional construction. A free in home consultation gives you an exact price, accurate to the penny, so you can judge the value on real numbers.
American Shower Company replaces showers and tubs for Wisconsin homeowners in Green Bay, Milwaukee, Madison and beyond, including Appleton, Oshkosh and Fond du Lac in Northeast Wisconsin, with its own employees and two system lines, Premium Samuel Mueller Systems and Signature BathWraps® Systems. Many installs finish in as little as one day, and most tub to shower conversions are one day jobs when the new base and walls fit the old space. Bigger jobs take longer: Becca K. wrote in a Google review that her crew "put in a full 12 hour day" to replace a whirlpool. Many Green Bay and Fox Valley bathrooms date from the 1960s and 1970s, so damage behind older walls is a common reason a job runs past one day. A free in home consultation sets your timeline and an exact price.
A full remodel that moves walls, plumbing and flooring takes weeks, while a shower or tub replacement in the same footprint is often finished in one day. The gap comes from the trades involved: a full remodel stacks demolition, rough plumbing, inspections, tile, cure time and finish work, each on its own visit. A same footprint replacement uses a one piece base and wall panels, either Premium Samuel Mueller Systems in solid surface or Signature BathWraps® Systems in acrylic, so there is no tile or grout to cure. Real installs vary. Jean S. wrote in a Google review about "getting a brand new shower in just one day," and Becca K.'s crew "put in a full 12 hour day" to replace a whirlpool. Damage found behind the old walls adds time, and you approve that work first.
Usually one day or less when the new shower goes into the old footprint, because the old unit comes out and the new base, walls and valve go in during the same visit. Krzysztof O. described a day where the installers had to drive back for the right tub and "still finished the job before dinner," and Tracey F. said hers was "done on time and less than a day." Two things can stretch it: wall or drain repairs found at tear out, which you approve before any added work, and Wisconsin weather on install day, since a storm that closes roads moves the appointment rather than the installers. Plan for a backup shower for the evening if the job is large, such as replacing a whirlpool.
A one day shower remodel replaces the shower or tub in its existing footprint with factory made pieces, while a traditional remodel builds the shower on site from backer board, tile and grout over several visits. That build order is why the one day job fits in a single visit: the base and wall panels arrive ready to install, so the crew removes the old unit, sets the new one, connects the valve and cleans up. Tracey F. described the contrast after her install: a shower at a previous home "took 2 weeks for the job to get done." Moving walls or drains is where traditional construction is still needed. Either way, the exact price is set at a free in home consultation, accurate to the penny, with no hidden fees.
A free in home consultation shows both system lines in your own bathroom and gives you an exact, personal price, accurate to the penny. Many installs are finished in as little as one day, backed by a Lifetime Warranty and Workmanship Guarantee.
Explore My OptionsExact price, accurate to the penny. Limited time: 50% off installation.
Before you go: see your options and get an exact price, accurate to the penny.